Skip to content

What the sources said

What the sources say

What they praise most

  • StoryThe mystery kept the reviewer invested throughout.GmanLivesat 22:00
  • CombatEnemy attacks are telegraphed, so good dodge timing makes combat feel strategic.GmanLivesat 10:50
  • DifficultyLimited ammo and healing make resource management create effective tension.GamingBoltat 6:25

What they criticise

  • StoryThe final act feels like it coasts instead of delivering a memorable ending.GamingBoltat 7:09
  • CombatCombat is fairly basic and doesn't stand out much.GamingBoltat 6:29
  • DifficultyRarely overly challenging, though some sections needed several retries.GamingBoltat 5:24

Where the sources agree, and where they don't

They agree on

  • PerformanceAll 3 sources criticise it

They disagree on

  • CombatGamingBolt criticises it · GmanLives praises it and criticises it · Más Menos Trece criticises it · The Sphere Hunter praises it · IXBT Games praises it and criticises it · Leya蕾雅 praises it · 3GordosB criticises it · Ktowho criticises it · Eslam ProPlayer praises it and criticises it · El Búnker S.A. criticises it · Only Roguelikes criticises it · GamingByte criticises it · Nuevebits praises it and criticises it · BL33DL0VE praises it and criticises it · GoneNow praises it and criticises it
  • StoryGamingBolt criticises it · GmanLives praises it · The Sphere Hunter praises it · IXBT Games praises it · Leya蕾雅 praises it and criticises it · 3GordosB praises it · Ktowho praises it and criticises it · Eslam ProPlayer praises it · Only Roguelikes praises it · Nuevebits praises it · BL33DL0VE praises it and criticises it · GoneNow praises it and criticises it
  • DifficultyGamingBolt praises it and criticises it · GmanLives praises it and criticises it · Más Menos Trece criticises it · The Sphere Hunter praises it · IXBT Games praises it · Leya蕾雅 praises it · 3GordosB praises it and criticises it · Ktowho praises it and criticises it · Eslam ProPlayer praises it · GamingByte praises it · Nuevebits criticises it · BL33DL0VE criticises it · GoneNow praises it
  • LengthIXBT Games criticises it · Only Roguelikes praises it

Only the sources we have a review from are listed. A source missing here is one we have no review from for this game — not proof that it said nothing about it, and not a verdict against it.

  1. GamingBolt

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.1,350,000 subscribersChannel
    Must playReviewed in English
    Recommended for
    Fans of atmospheric survival horror with clever puzzles.
    With these reservations
    The story lacks a standout finale, exploration can be repetitive and unclear, and combat is basic.

    Combat

    • CriticismCombat is fairly basic and doesn't stand out much.at 6:29

    Story

    • CriticismThe final act feels like it coasts instead of delivering a memorable ending.at 7:09

    Difficulty

    • PraiseLimited ammo and healing make resource management create effective tension.at 6:25
    • CriticismRarely overly challenging, though some sections needed several retries.at 5:24
    Open the original review
  2. GmanLives

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.836,000 subscribersChannel
    RecommendedReviewed in English
    Recommended for
    Survival horror fans, especially those who love Silent Hill and Lynchian weirdness, or anyone who wants a strange side-scroller.
    With these reservations
    Clunky combat, repetitive bosses, scarce ammo, annoying suicide enemies, performance dips, and no New Game Plus.

    Combat

    • PraiseEnemy attacks are telegraphed, so good dodge timing makes combat feel strategic.at 10:50
    • CriticismThe controls are slow and clunky, which is intentional but takes time to adjust to.at 8:24
    • CriticismBoss fights follow nearly the same run-dodge-shoot pattern each time.at 18:51
    • CriticismSuicide-style exploding enemies feel like a cheap, frustrating design choice.at 20:27

    Story

    • PraiseThe mystery kept the reviewer invested throughout.at 22:00

    Difficulty

    • PraiseOn the recommended survival horror difficulty, the challenge usually feels fair.at 12:23
    • CriticismAmmunition is very scarce, and preset item locations can leave players stuck.at 16:59

    Performance

    • CriticismSome areas run very choppily, and driver updates didn't fully fix the frame rate.at 6:00
    Open the original review
  3. Más Menos Trece

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.667,000 subscribersChannel
    No Verdict declaredReviewed in Spanish

    Combat

    • CriticismLe preocupa quedarse sin munición y sin armas cuerpo a cuerpo.at 47:44

    Difficulty

    • CriticismLe parece muy dura la dificultad, sobre todo en el modo difícil.at 44:19
    Open the original review
  4. The Sphere Hunter

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.603,000 subscribersChannel
    RecommendedReviewed in English
    Recommended for
    Fans of detective mysteries, survival horror, and dark, dreamlike adventures about self-discovery.
    With these reservations
    The narrator acts in the game and admits bias. He says he is not an expert in Metroidvanias.

    Combat

    • PraiseThe manual reload mini-game changes with each weapon type and feels tense in combat.at 7:51
    • PraiseTools like the crowbar can also be used as weapons, which changes how you use them.at 9:37
    • PraiseMementos offer stat changes and let you build different combat styles.at 14:13
    • PraiseThe monster variety is healthy, with grounded, crawling and aerial threats and status effects.at 12:32

    Story

    • PraiseThe writing is strong, with distinct characters and dark themes handled with maturity.at 17:45
    • PraiseThe story withholds explanations on purpose, leaving answers to be found by searching.at 17:05

    Difficulty

    • PraiseFour difficulty levels; the middle setting is a balanced choice, while the hardest is very punishing.at 13:27
    Open the original review
  5. IXBT Games

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.513,000 subscribersChannel
    RecommendedReviewed in Russian
    Recommended for
    Любителям хорроров старой школы в духе Silent Hill и метроидваний.
    With these reservations
    Боевка и боссы простоваты, сюжет сложно понять, а затянутые возвраты к сохранениям могут утомлять.

    Combat

    • PraiseСовмещение боевого хоррора и метроидвании даёт необычные ощущения от знакомых идей.at 2:19
    • CriticismБоссы однотипны и простоваты, а разнообразие врагов и способностей героя ограничено.at 15:59

    Story

    • PraiseСюжет почти не объясняет себя и не перегружает диалогами, что помогает атмосфере.at 4:19

    Difficulty

    • PraiseНа третьей по счёту сложности баланс выглядит выверенным, а напряжение держится.at 9:35

    Length

    • CriticismБлиже к финалу однообразные возвраты за предметами начинают надоедать.at 15:22
    Open the original review
  6. Leya蕾雅

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.339,000 subscribersChannel
    No Verdict declaredReviewed in Chinese (China)
    Recommended for
    Aficionados al survival horror que aceptan una narrativa simbólica y ambigua.
    With these reservations
    El guion es poco original porque toma muchos elementos de referentes anteriores.

    Combat

    • PraiseEl entorno de 2D metroidvania hace que las mecánicas clásicas de supervivencia se sientan frescas.at 33:36

    Story

    • PraiseLos vacíos y las metáforas dejan que el jugador interprete el final, y el autor lo ve con buenos ojos.at 33:10
    • CriticismLa trama toma demasiados elementos de obras anteriores, lo que resta originalidad al guion.at 33:18

    Difficulty

    • PraiseLos recursos limitados y el coste de guardar generan una tensión constante y bien planteada.at 2:58
    Open the original review
  7. 3GordosB

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.220,000 subscribersChannel
    RecommendedReviewed in Spanish
    Recommended for
    Fans del survival horror.
    With these reservations
    El combate es algo tosco y la barra de estamina puede resultar molesta en algunos momentos.

    Combat

    • CriticismLe parece algo rígido, sobre todo en las peleas contra jefes, que pueden hacerse pesadas.at 6:17

    Story

    • PraiseLos personajes no dan respuestas directas, lo que mantiene las dudas abiertas.at 7:44

    Difficulty

    • PraiseConsidera bien equilibrado el balance entre recursos escasos y enemigos.at 4:58
    • PraiseDisfrutó los acertijos, que le parecen divertidos y originales.at 5:55
    • CriticismGuardar la partida cuesta monedas y los recursos en las máquinas son caros.at 5:40
    Open the original review
  8. Ktowho

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.89,900 subscribersChannel
    No Verdict declaredReviewed in Russian

    Combat

    • CriticismЖуки в туалете наносят много урона, и он не понял, как с ними справляться.at 8:42
    • CriticismБоссы почти одинаковы по тактике: много здоровья и пара атак.at 13:21

    Story

    • PraiseВторое дно и несколько концовок выстроены удачно.at 41:32
    • CriticismПосле большей части игры ответов на сюжетные вопросы почти нет.at 29:55

    Difficulty

    • PraiseЦена ошибки ощутима, и он считает это признаком качества.at 10:47
    • CriticismНа высокой сложности монет мало, а сохраняться дорого.at 10:10

    Performance

    • CriticismСейврумы не работали, что его сильно раздражало.at 32:29
    Open the original review
  9. Eslam ProPlayer

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.58,800 subscribersChannel
    Recommended with reservationsReviewed in Arabic
    Recommended for
    محبو ألعاب الرعب الاستكشافية التي تعتمد على جمع الأدلة وربط الأحداث.
    With these reservations
    تنوع الأعداء محدود، والتحكم في الحركة ثقيل أحيانا، وبعض المواجهات تفقد توترها مع الوقت.

    Combat

    • Praiseإدارة الاستامينا وتوقيت الضربات والتفادي تضيف تخطيطا للمواجهات.at 9:44
    • Criticismتنوع الأعداء قليل، وكان يتمنى تنوعا أكبر في الشكل والسلوك.at 9:14
    • Criticismحركة الشخصية ثقيلة أحيانا وغير سلسة، وهذا يؤثر على اللعب.at 9:51

    Story

    • Praiseالقصة تكشف المعلومات تدريجيا، وكل إجابة تفتح أسئلة جديدة.at 4:34

    Difficulty

    • Praiseالموارد المحدودes تجعل كل قرار مهما، ويضطر اللاعب للتفكير قبل التصرف.at 7:53
    Open the original review
  10. El Búnker S.A.

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.50,400 subscribersChannel
    Recommended with reservationsReviewed in Spanish
    Recommended for
    Aficionados a los juegos de supervivencia y metroidvania.
    With these reservations
    El combate es flojo y los enemigos resultan poco interesantes por su resistencia.

    Combat

    • CriticismConsidera el combate mediocre, aunque no lo califica de terrible.at 1:01
    • CriticismSugiere un modo de dificultad intermedio para que los enemigos no sean tan resistentes.at 1:13
    • CriticismCada encuentro se siente como un trámite que no aporta nada.at 1:21
    Open the original review
  11. Only Roguelikes

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.42,600 subscribersChannel
    Recommended with reservationsReviewed in Spanish
    Recommended for
    Quien disfrute de metroidvanias y del terror psicológico al estilo Silent Hill o Twin Peaks.
    With these reservations
    El combate contra jefes es tosco y las animaciones son lentas.

    Combat

    • CriticismEl combate contra los jefes resulta tosco y lento, y lastra la experiencia.at 1:41:12

    Story

    • PraiseLa historia se explica en el final y resulta interesante.at 12:36:10

    Performance

    • CriticismSe menciona que la animación de los enemigos y los combates son poco fluidos.at 12:28:21

    Length

    • PraiseAfirma que la duración de unas 12 horas le parece adecuada para el juego.at 12:11:09
    Open the original review
  12. GamingByte

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.10,100 subscribersChannel
    No Verdict declaredReviewed in English
    Recommended for
    Players who enjoy slow, careful horror exploration with backtracking.
    With these reservations
    Clunky combat, especially in larger encounters and bosses.

    Combat

    • CriticismThe fighting is the weakest element, and boss fights frustrate.at 1:19
    • CriticismDodging is timing-heavy, and one miss can cost a big chunk of health.at 1:30

    Difficulty

    • PraisePuzzles are engaging and clear rather than baffling.at 0:48
    • PraiseMultiple difficulty settings let players set how much combat pressure they face.at 1:36
    Open the original review
  13. Nuevebits

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.8,540 subscribersChannel
    Must playReviewed in Spanish
    Recommended for
    Jugadores nuevos al survival horror o que no conocen las obras de referencia.
    With these reservations
    El Metroidvania es más horizontal que vertical y pierde parte de su fuerza. Los referentes pueden cansar a quien lleva décadas jugando al género.

    Combat

    • PraiseCombate bien pensado para el tipo de juego que es.at 21:41
    • CriticismEl combate puede resultar algo pesado en ocasiones.at 21:37

    Story

    • PraiseNarrativa compleja que maneja bien el terror psicológico.at 1:11
    • PraiseEquilibrio entre lo que cuenta y la forma de contarlo.at 24:39
    • PraiseSugiere más de lo que explica y evita soltar el lore de golpe.at 27:17

    Difficulty

    • CriticismLa esquiva frente al Némesis no es clara y falla a menudo.at 15:09
    Open the original review
  14. BL33DL0VE

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.4,200 subscribersChannel
    Must playReviewed in Russian
    Recommended for
    Любителям метроидваний, сурвайвал-хорроров и историй про глухую провинцию.
    With these reservations
    Автор сознательно не разбирает недостатки и признаёт, что сюжет не особо оригинален.

    Combat

    • PraiseБлижнего оружия много, и у каждого образца свои дистанция, урон и скорость удара.at 7:45
    • PraiseМини-игра при лечении и ремонте добавляет напряжения в бою.at 8:38
    • PraiseОгнестрельное оружие выбирается по удобству, а не по урону, и все стволы остаются полезными до конца.at 10:26
    • PraiseСистема тринкетов позволяет собирать разные билды и менять их в любой момент.at 12:38
    • CriticismПрицеливание без перекрестия требует привыкания, хотя есть опция лазерного прицела.at 9:32

    Story

    • PraiseПодача истории и внимание к деталям доставляют удовольствие.at 3:56
    • CriticismСюжет не предлагает особых откровений, и многое ясно уже в первый час.at 3:36

    Difficulty

    • CriticismАвтосохранений нет, а сохраниться можно только через телефон за доллар.at 20:26
    Open the original review
  15. GoneNow

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.2,590 subscribersChannel
    Recommended with reservationsReviewed in English
    Recommended for
    Players who enjoy exploration-heavy horror with lots of progression and can tolerate clunky combat.
    With these reservations
    The story is derivative and its characters are flat, and combat is janky, with unreliable reloads and no pause for the inventory.

    Combat

    • PraiseThe friction in combat makes fights tense and unpredictable, which suits the horror tone.at 8:24
    • CriticismMovement, turning, melee range, and the reload minigame feel unreliable, and the game keeps running while you open the inventory.at 7:41

    Story

    • PraiseThe endings are highly praised and leave the experience on a strong note.at 15:20
    • CriticismThe story feels derivative, borrowing heavily from Twin Peaks and similar works.at 9:46
    • CriticismThe characters are written flatly and give the reviewer little reason to care.at 12:38

    Difficulty

    • PraiseDead ends are rarely fatal, since the reviewer can switch to another lead instead of reloading repeatedly.at 6:35
    Open the original review

Are you the creator of one of these reviews? Ask us to remove it.

Full description and technical details

Silver Pines is a Survival Horror set in small town America. Fight nightmarish terrors and solve puzzles, while carefully managing your scarce resources as you uncover the mysteries that could hold the key to redemption.

  • Release date:2026-10-08
  • Studio:Wych Elm
  • Genres:Adventure, Indie
  • Platforms:Xbox Series X|S, PC (Microsoft Windows), PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch