Skip to content

What the sources said

What the sources say

What they praise most

What they criticise

Where the sources agree, and where they don't

They disagree on

  • StorySwitchUp praises it · 3GordosB praises it and criticises it · FuryForged praises it · The Singleplayer Squad praises it and criticises it · Indie Chris praises it · Jack Crawford praises it and criticises it · Ernogon praises it
  • DifficultyReal Civil Engineer praises it and criticises it · Aliensrock praises it and criticises it · SwitchUp praises it · 3GordosB praises it · FuryForged praises it and criticises it · The Singleplayer Squad criticises it · Boss Door praises it and criticises it · Indie Chris criticises it · Jack Crawford praises it and criticises it · Ernogon praises it
  • LengthReal Civil Engineer praises it · Aliensrock praises it · SwitchUp praises it · 3GordosB praises it · FuryForged praises it · The Singleplayer Squad praises it and criticises it · Jack Crawford praises it and criticises it · Ernogon praises it

Only the sources we have a review from are listed. A source missing here is one we have no review from for this game — not proof that it said nothing about it, and not a verdict against it.

  1. Real Civil Engineer

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.2,900,000 subscribersChannel
    No Verdict declaredReviewed in English
    With these reservations
    Some puzzles are confusing, and the reviewer got stuck on several of them.

    Difficulty

    • PraiseThe rewind and undo options make trial and error less punishing.at 21:21
    • PraiseMirror puzzles are clever and satisfying once solved.at 11:18
    • CriticismSome puzzles were hard to work out and took a long time to solve.at 16:18

    Length

    • PraiseSees the game as having a lot of content to explore.at 38:16
    Open the original review
  2. Aliensrock

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.810,000 subscribersChannel
    No Verdict declaredReviewed in English

    Difficulty

    • PraiseCalls a puzzle impressive and says overcoming being stuck is the best part of puzzle games.at 23:01
    • CriticismSays the two-mirror mechanic is overpowered in this game.at 11:46

    Length

    • PraiseAppreciates the alt key that speeds up time, so waiting is shorter.at 13:48

    Co-op

    • PraisePraises the two-character lily pad solution as a cool, enjoyable puzzle.at 36:39
    Open the original review
  3. SwitchUp

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.433,000 subscribersChannel
    RecommendedReviewed in British English
    Recommended for
    Players who don't usually enjoy puzzle games may still want to try it.
    With these reservations
    Frame rate dips in some overworld areas, though most puzzling happens elsewhere.

    Story

    • PraiseThe story is praised as a real narrative, with multiple endings that are unusual for the genre.at 8:20

    Difficulty

    • PraiseDifficulty rises gradually by adding characters and rules, without becoming overwhelming.at 4:13

    Performance

    • CriticismTargets 60 fps but drops in some puzzle areas, with the overworld struggling the most.at 9:41

    Length

    • PraiseThe reviewer estimates about 250 hours of playtime at their pace.at 10:13
    Open the original review
  4. 3GordosB

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.220,000 subscribersChannel
    RecommendedReviewed in Spanish
    Recommended for
    Quien disfrute de acertijos exigentes y tenga paciencia, sobre todo seguidores de Jonathan Blow.
    With these reservations
    Voces irregulares y subtítulos con fallas; el desarrollador ya trabaja en corregirlos según la nota del juego. Hay que llegar con mente abierta.

    Story

    • PraiseLas voces son mayormente buenas y dan pistas de la historia de cada región.at 11:05
    • CriticismAlgunas voces suenan planas, sobre todo en el sur, y los subtítulos se desincronizan o desaparecen.at 11:14

    Difficulty

    • PraiseAcertijos muy bien diseñados y exigentes; el autor dice que nadie hace puzzles como los de Blow.at 10:25
    • PraiseEl juego no guía al jugador, así que cada solución se siente más especial.at 12:10

    Length

    • PraiseContenido enorme: entre 250 y 500 horas según el desarrollador.at 12:25
    Open the original review
  5. FuryForged

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.205,000 subscribersChannel
    Must playReviewed in English
    Recommended for
    Puzzle fans who enjoy varied mechanics, secret hunting and knowledge gates.
    With these reservations
    Some puzzles are very hard and open-ended ones invite overthinking. The footage is pre-release and may differ at launch. Players who prefer less variety may not enjoy it as much.

    Story

    • PraiseFinds the lore mysterious and says he is eager to learn more as the plot thickens.at 20:51

    Difficulty

    • PraiseDescribes the puzzles as challenging but satisfying, and ambitious in scope.at 2:00
    • CriticismSome puzzles are very hard, and players will get stuck at times.at 15:15
    • CriticismThe Skipping Stones world was the hardest early on, and its open design makes overthinking easy.at 8:12

    Length

    • PraiseHas logged over 100 hours and calls it the most addictive puzzle game he has played.at 1:06
    • PraiseStresses that the game is huge in size, with over a thousand puzzles.at 1:51
    Open the original review
  6. The Singleplayer Squad

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.64,800 subscribersChannel
    Recommended with reservationsReviewed in English
    Recommended for
    Players who enjoy tough puzzle games and are willing to put up with heavy challenge.
    With these reservations
    Brutal difficulty, no hint system, some clumsy movement when moving several objects, a very large puzzle count that can exhaust, and weak writing.

    Story

    • PraiseFinds the world's central mystery interesting.at 3:01
    • CriticismDialogue is long-winded and the writing is not always engaging.at 3:03

    Difficulty

    • CriticismCan be brutally hard, with no proper hint system and puzzles that rely on trial and error.at 2:27

    Length

    • PraiseLarge interconnected world that could mean hundreds of hours of play.at 0:17
    • CriticismOver a thousand puzzles, with little downtime between them, could become exhausting.at 2:48

    Price

    • PraiseFor $30, it offers a lot of content, and you don't need to solve every puzzle to finish.at 3:23
    Open the original review
  7. Recommended with reservationsReviewed in English
    Recommended for
    Puzzle fans. The reviewer says others should become puzzle fans to enjoy it.
    With these reservations
    The four campaigns vary in quality, and Mirror Isles and Lonely Homes felt weaker than Hauling Heroes. The reviewer had not reached the later part where the heroes meet, since a day-one patch reset their progress.

    Difficulty

    • PraiseThe early game eases players into its mechanics, and each puzzle shows something new instead of being hard for its own sake.at 2:52
    • PraiseFrustration from long stalls disappears once a stage is solved.at 3:45
    • CriticismThe reviewer often felt very stuck and sometimes doubted that finding the solution was worth it.at 3:33
    Open the original review
  8. Indie Chris

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.2,730 subscribersChannel
    No Verdict declaredReviewed in English

    Story

    • PraiseLikes the philosophical themes and finds the story's ideas intriguing.at 16:10

    Difficulty

    • CriticismDislikes the automatic hint that flashes at them; would rather solve puzzles on their own.at 47:55
    Open the original review
  9. Recommended with reservationsTheir own score: 6 / 10Reviewed in English
    Recommended for
    Players new to sokoban-style puzzles or wanting a long, comfortable puzzle game, and fans who want an on-ramp to harder puzzle games.
    With these reservations
    He found it too easy and lacking in late-game idea density and complexity, and it feels less polished than The Witness.

    Story

    • PraiseStory and tone improve as the game goes on, becoming more to his taste.at 1:00:44
    • CriticismWriting and narrative feel lower effort than in The Witness or Braid.at 59:05

    Difficulty

    • PraiseThe gentle difficulty curve suits an ideal player well, and he respects that design choice even though it wasn't right for him.at 44:19
    • PraiseWorks well as an on-ramp for players who struggle with harder sokoban-style games.at 25:56
    • CriticismDifficulty stays roughly flat across layers, so the deeper parts don't escalate as much as he expected.at 12:24
    • CriticismLater puzzles feel too simple and less complex than he wanted, so they are less memorable.at 17:20

    Length

    • PraisePacing is comfortable enough that players can sit down and play for many hours.at 31:52
    • CriticismThe game is very long, and the time spent felt only borderline worth it for him.at 7:27
    Open the original review
  10. Ernogon

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.112 subscribersChannel
    Must playReviewed in Russian
    Recommended for
    Para quien disfrute de los puzzles, para fans de The Witness y para quien quiera iniciarse en el género.
    With these reservations
    Solo ha jugado cerca de una cuarta parte, así que aún no valora la metahistoria. Falta una opción para silenciar la música con la ventana inactiva.

    Story

    • PraiseLas historias de los personajes van dentro de los puzzles, y hay una metahistoria que no revela.at 17:32
    • PraiseLas ideas filosóficas se presentan con tacto, sin moralizar ni imponer una visión.at 21:53

    Difficulty

    • PraiseLas primeras головоломки son muy sencillas, pero luego se vuelven profundas y exigen planificar.at 6:18
    • PraiseNo hay castigo: cualquier acción se puede deshacer y no se puede perder.at 16:03
    • PraiseLa solución depende de entender las mecánicas, no de reunir objetos en otras zonas.at 9:15
    • PraiseUna головоломка le costó dos horas, pero se resolvió rápido al entender la mecánica correcta.at 7:49

    Length

    • PraiseSegún los desarrolladores hay más de mil головоломок; el autor calcula haber jugado cerca del 20 %.at 6:25
    Open the original review

Are you the creator of one of these reviews? Ask us to remove it.

Full description and technical details

From director Jonathan Blow (Braid, The Witness), Order of the Sinking Star is a narrative adventure set in a realm of magic and enigma. Solve over 1000 interconnected, hand-crafted puzzles, discover unique playable heroes, master evolving gameplay mechanics, and decipher a grand mystery.

  • Release date:2026-10-08
  • Studio:Thekla, Inc
  • Genres:Puzzle, Adventure
  • Platforms:Nintendo Switch 2, PC (Microsoft Windows), PlayStation 5