What the sources said
What the sources say
What they praise most
- DifficultyMirror puzzles are clever and satisfying once solved.Real Civil Engineerat 11:18
- StoryThe story is praised as a real narrative, with multiple endings that are unusual for the genre.SwitchUpat 8:20
- LengthSees the game as having a lot of content to explore.Real Civil Engineerat 38:16
What they criticise
- DifficultySome puzzles were hard to work out and took a long time to solve.Real Civil Engineerat 16:18
- StoryAlgunas voces suenan planas, sobre todo en el sur, y los subtítulos se desincronizan o desaparecen.3GordosBat 11:14
- LengthOver a thousand puzzles, with little downtime between them, could become exhausting.The Singleplayer Squadat 2:48
Where the sources agree, and where they don't
They disagree on
- StorySwitchUp praises it · 3GordosB praises it and criticises it · FuryForged praises it · The Singleplayer Squad praises it and criticises it · Indie Chris praises it · Jack Crawford praises it and criticises it · Ernogon praises it
- DifficultyReal Civil Engineer praises it and criticises it · Aliensrock praises it and criticises it · SwitchUp praises it · 3GordosB praises it · FuryForged praises it and criticises it · The Singleplayer Squad criticises it · Boss Door praises it and criticises it · Indie Chris criticises it · Jack Crawford praises it and criticises it · Ernogon praises it
- LengthReal Civil Engineer praises it · Aliensrock praises it · SwitchUp praises it · 3GordosB praises it · FuryForged praises it · The Singleplayer Squad praises it and criticises it · Jack Crawford praises it and criticises it · Ernogon praises it
Only the sources we have a review from are listed. A source missing here is one we have no review from for this game — not proof that it said nothing about it, and not a verdict against it.
Combat
We have no claim about this aspect in the reviews shown here. It may well have been covered and we simply have not captured it, so this is not a sign that nobody said anything about it.
Story
FuryForged
PraiseChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- PraiseFinds the lore mysterious and says he is eager to learn more as the plot thickens.at 20:51
The Singleplayer Squad
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.Indie Chris
PraiseChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- PraiseLikes the philosophical themes and finds the story's ideas intriguing.at 16:10
Jack Crawford
MixedChannelDeclared tie: early access · at 34:39- CriticismWriting and narrative feel lower effort than in The Witness or Braid.at 59:05
- PraiseStory and tone improve as the game goes on, becoming more to his taste.at 1:00:44
Difficulty
Real Civil Engineer
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.Aliensrock
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.FuryForged
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.The Singleplayer Squad
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismCan be brutally hard, with no proper hint system and puzzles that rely on trial and error.at 2:27
Boss Door
MixedChannelDeclared tie: free key · at 0:00- PraiseThe early game eases players into its mechanics, and each puzzle shows something new instead of being hard for its own sake.at 2:52
- CriticismThe reviewer often felt very stuck and sometimes doubted that finding the solution was worth it.at 3:33
- PraiseFrustration from long stalls disappears once a stage is solved.at 3:45
Indie Chris
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismDislikes the automatic hint that flashes at them; would rather solve puzzles on their own.at 47:55
Jack Crawford
MixedChannelDeclared tie: early access · at 34:39- CriticismDifficulty stays roughly flat across layers, so the deeper parts don't escalate as much as he expected.at 12:24
- CriticismLater puzzles feel too simple and less complex than he wanted, so they are less memorable.at 17:20
- PraiseThe gentle difficulty curve suits an ideal player well, and he respects that design choice even though it wasn't right for him.at 44:19
- PraiseWorks well as an on-ramp for players who struggle with harder sokoban-style games.at 25:56
Ernogon
PraiseChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- PraiseLas primeras головоломки son muy sencillas, pero luego se vuelven profundas y exigen planificar.at 6:18
- PraiseNo hay castigo: cualquier acción se puede deshacer y no se puede perder.at 16:03
- PraiseLa solución depende de entender las mecánicas, no de reunir objetos en otras zonas.at 9:15
- PraiseUna головоломка le costó dos horas, pero se resolvió rápido al entender la mecánica correcta.at 7:49
Performance
Length
Real Civil Engineer
PraiseChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- PraiseSees the game as having a lot of content to explore.at 38:16
Aliensrock
PraiseChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- PraiseAppreciates the alt key that speeds up time, so waiting is shorter.at 13:48
FuryForged
PraiseChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.The Singleplayer Squad
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.
Monetisation
We have no claim about this aspect in the reviews shown here. It may well have been covered and we simply have not captured it, so this is not a sign that nobody said anything about it.
Co-op
Aliensrock
PraiseChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- PraisePraises the two-character lily pad solution as a cool, enjoyable puzzle.at 36:39
Price
The Singleplayer Squad
PraiseChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- PraiseFor $30, it offers a lot of content, and you don't need to solve every puzzle to finish.at 3:23
Are you the creator of one of these reviews? Ask us to remove it.
Full description and technical details
From director Jonathan Blow (Braid, The Witness), Order of the Sinking Star is a narrative adventure set in a realm of magic and enigma. Solve over 1000 interconnected, hand-crafted puzzles, discover unique playable heroes, master evolving gameplay mechanics, and decipher a grand mystery.
- Release date:2026-10-08
- Studio:Thekla, Inc
- Genres:Puzzle, Adventure
- Platforms:Nintendo Switch 2, PC (Microsoft Windows), PlayStation 5