Skip to content

What the sources said

What the sources say

What they praise most

  • StoryСюжет цепляет и запутывает, персонажи запоминаются.StopGameat 24:47
  • CombatСтелс удобен: есть укрытия, обходные пути и возможность выглядывать из-за углов.StopGameat 20:18
  • DifficultyPuzzles are creative, make you think, and some are among the most memorable in the series.MoistCr1TiKaL Gamingat 6:04

What they criticise

  • StoryFound the lore a bit confusing, though the game still held together.Dawkoat 1:50:02
  • CombatУдары палкой ощущаются без веса, а враги атакуют резко и без паузы.StopGameat 20:33
  • DifficultyНеубиваемый преследователь почти неубиваем, а на сложной сложности врагов становится больше и урон выше.StopGameat 23:25

Where the sources agree, and where they don't

They agree on

  • LengthAll 4 sources criticise it

They disagree on

  • CombatStopGame praises it and criticises it · Dawko criticises it · GENuINE993 criticises it · MoistCr1TiKaL Gaming praises it and criticises it · GmanLives criticises it · Cohh praises it and criticises it · XGTV UA praises it and criticises it · BaityPlays criticises it · Under The Mayo praises it and criticises it · Albert Gil criticises it · Shredded Otaku praises it and criticises it · Hikikomori Media praises it and criticises it
  • StoryStopGame praises it · Dawko criticises it · GENuINE993 praises it and criticises it · MoistCr1TiKaL Gaming praises it and criticises it · PSI Gaming praises it and criticises it · XGTV UA praises it and criticises it · Under The Mayo praises it and criticises it · Albert Gil praises it and criticises it · Shredded Otaku praises it · Hikikomori Media praises it and criticises it · Molotov Game praises it
  • DifficultyStopGame criticises it · Dawko criticises it · GENuINE993 criticises it · MoistCr1TiKaL Gaming praises it · GmanLives criticises it · XGTV UA praises it and criticises it · BaityPlays praises it and criticises it · Under The Mayo criticises it · Albert Gil praises it and criticises it · Hikikomori Media praises it and criticises it
  • PerformanceStopGame praises it and criticises it · Dawko criticises it · GENuINE993 criticises it · XGTV UA praises it and criticises it · Under The Mayo criticises it · Albert Gil criticises it · Hikikomori Media criticises it
  • PriceGmanLives praises it · XGTV UA criticises it

Only the sources we have a review from are listed. A source missing here is one we have no review from for this game — not proof that it said nothing about it, and not a verdict against it.

  1. StopGame

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.2,410,000 subscribersChannel
    Recommended with reservationsReviewed in Russian
    Recommended for
    Тем, кому нравятся атмосферный стелс от первого лица и сюжет, и кто терпим к грубоватому бою.
    With these reservations
    Слабый ближний бой, неубиваемый преследователь, темнота, перекос сложности и мало нового контента после первого прохождения.

    Combat

    • PraiseСтелс удобен: есть укрытия, обходные пути и возможность выглядывать из-за углов.at 20:18
    • CriticismУдары палкой ощущаются без веса, а враги атакуют резко и без паузы.at 20:33
    • CriticismБлижнее оружие ломается почти сразу, хватает на пару врагов.at 21:12

    Story

    • PraiseСюжет цепляет и запутывает, персонажи запоминаются.at 24:47

    Difficulty

    • CriticismНеубиваемый преследователь почти неубиваем, а на сложной сложности врагов становится больше и урон выше.at 23:25

    Performance

    • PraiseНа 60 кадрах без вылетов и просадок, хотя в отзывах на это жалуются.at 25:37
    • CriticismПри подгрузке новых частей уровня бывают статтеры.at 25:54

    Length

    • CriticismНового контента мало: меняются только финальные ролики.at 24:07
    Open the original review
  2. Dawko

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.2,270,000 subscribersChannel
    Recommended with reservationsReviewed in English
    With these reservations
    Gameplay feels slow and tedious in places, the boss fight is weak, and performance issues appear during play.

    Combat

    • CriticismFelt the final boss fight was underwhelming.at 1:50:04

    Story

    • CriticismFound the lore a bit confusing, though the game still held together.at 1:50:02

    Difficulty

    • CriticismFound the puzzles and back-and-forth progression complicated.at 1:50:30

    Performance

    • CriticismSaid the optimization is poor, with lag and a camera that froze during play.at 1:13:24
    Open the original review
  3. GENuINE993

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.1,260,000 subscribersChannel
    Recommended with reservationsReviewed in Spanish
    With these reservations
    Puzles muy pesados, armas que se gastan rápido, poca rejugabilidad y bloqueos durante la partida.

    Combat

    • CriticismLas armas cuerpo a cuerpo se gastan enseguida y el combate se vuelve complicado.at 2:59:18

    Story

    • PraiseAl principio la trama le parece prometedora.at 36:48
    • CriticismAdmite no entender varios puntos de la trama al final.at 9:20:28

    Difficulty

    • CriticismConsidera los puzles pesados, de lo peor del juego.at 9:18:47

    Performance

    • CriticismSufrió bloqueos y bugs durante la partida.at 8:22:23

    Length

    • CriticismLo ve excesivamente largo y poco rejugable.at 9:18:17
    Open the original review
  4. MoistCr1TiKaL Gaming

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.1,150,000 subscribersChannel
    Recommended with reservationsReviewed in English
    Recommended for
    Players willing to put up with the stealth for the story and puzzles.
    With these reservations
    The stealth is slow and tedious, with enemies that stay in place for long periods and no real stealth mechanics. Killing too many enemies locks you into a bad ending.

    Combat

    • PraiseThe villain section offers a more action-focused change of pace that suits the character.at 9:06
    • CriticismStealth is the main weakness: enemies are passed by waiting for them to look away, with few tools and little depth.at 1:08
    • CriticismMelee combat with improvised weapons feels clunky and unsatisfying.at 1:48
    • CriticismThe reviewer finds the forced waiting around enemies tedious and says it drags down the pace of exploration.at 2:10

    Story

    • PraiseThe story keeps the reviewer engaged, guessing, and invested in the characters.at 7:18
    • PraiseThe narrative and characters are considered solid overall.at 8:26
    • CriticismCharacters are underdeveloped early on, with most of their backstory found in documents rather than cutscenes.at 7:24

    Difficulty

    • PraisePuzzles are creative, make you think, and some are among the most memorable in the series.at 6:04
    Open the original review
  5. GmanLives

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.836,000 subscribersChannel
    Not recommendedReviewed in English
    Recommended for
    Fans who mainly care about atmosphere and symbolism.
    With these reservations
    Clunky combat, slow and unclear stealth, unfair one-hit enemies, tedious puzzles and fetch quests, and a single boss. Visuals and Simon's sections are praised.

    Combat

    • CriticismMelee is just attack and block, with no heavy attack, dodge, or parry.at 8:53

    Difficulty

    • CriticismRanged enemies can hit without warning, so being detected is usually fatal.at 13:27
    • CriticismA one-hit-kill enemy must be avoided because no weapon affects it, and being seen means death.at 20:23

    Length

    • CriticismSlow walking and crouch speeds pad the game, and trial-and-error sections drag it out.at 14:37

    Price

    • PraiseKonami is not charging full price, which he sees as a sign they are aware of the game's quality.at 24:19
    Open the original review
  6. PSI Gaming

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.349,000 subscribersChannel
    No Verdict declaredReviewed in Spanish
    With these reservations
    Puede resultar confuso si no se conocen el contexto y la cronología de la historia.

    Story

    • PraiseLe gusta la idea de construir el mundo a partir del trauma colectivo de muchas personas.at 51:06
    • PraiseRecrea bien la atmósfera de soledad, paranoia y misticismo de la saga.at 4:54
    • CriticismConsidera la trama confusa, porque cuesta establecer qué está pasando realmente.at 38:35
    Open the original review
  7. Cohh

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.330,000 subscribersChannel
    No Verdict declaredReviewed in English
    With these reservations
    Doubts about the stealth, which the reviewer finds too much at times.

    Combat

    • PraiseLikes the lean mechanic, which helps the player avoid enemy detection around corners.at 0:18
    • CriticismStealth feels excessive so far, and the reviewer is not yet convinced by it.at 0:08
    Open the original review
  8. XGTV UA

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.221,000 subscribersChannel
    Only for fansTheir own score: 6 / 10Reviewed in Ukrainian
    Recommended for
    Запеклим фанатам серії, які вже вирішили купити гру на релізі.
    With these reservations
    Душний стелс через невразливого монстра, мало ресурсів і завелика ціна за 8–9 годин гри.

    Combat

    • PraiseСистема блоків і контрударів працює добре.at 9:40
    • PraiseСтелс, особливо в першій третині гри, викликав позитивні емоції.at 7:39
    • CriticismЗвуки зброї та анімації слабкі, відчуття ваги пострілу відсутнє.at 10:02
    • CriticismБосів дуже мало.at 11:24

    Story

    • PraiseСюжетна лінія медсестри Зої єдина виділяється позитивно.at 5:46
    • CriticismСюжетний конфлікт здається банальним і нудним, без глибини.at 4:04
    • CriticismГоловний герой Саймон пасивний і майже без емоцій, його арка слабка.at 5:17

    Difficulty

    • PraiseГоловоломки потребують логіки й уваги, і вони приємно здивували.at 14:05
    • CriticismНевразливий монстр і довга анімація смерті роблять стелс душним.at 7:57
    • CriticismРесурсів мало, особливо на середній складності.at 12:38
    • CriticismТекст підказки для головоломок не змінюється залежно від складності.at 13:17

    Performance

    • PraiseПродуктивність на 1080p з DLSS прийнятна, близько 90–100 кадрів.at 16:13
    • CriticismОдин раз персонаж провалився крізь підлогу після катсцени, але баг швидко вирішився.at 16:21

    Length

    • CriticismПроходиться за 8–9 годин, що мало для такої ціни.at 18:05

    Price

    • CriticismЦіна 2150 грн за стандартну версію і 2600 за Deluxe завелика.at 17:51
    Open the original review
  9. BaityPlays

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.205,000 subscribersChannel
    Recommended with reservationsReviewed in Spanish
    Recommended for
    Jugadores pacientes a los que les guste el sigilo, los puzzles y el misterio.
    With these reservations
    Puzzles difíciles de entender, enemigo de sigilo impredecible y combate flojo.

    Combat

    • CriticismEl combate le parece flojo.at 37:19
    • CriticismEl enemigo de sigilo es impredecible y eso le quita gracia.at 4:13:31

    Difficulty

    • PraiseHasta cierto punto, los puzzles no le parecen excesivamente obtusos.at 2:04:26
    • CriticismLos puzzles finales son duros, y entender qué piden cuesta más que resolverlos.at 4:13:33
    Open the original review
  10. Under The Mayo

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.166,000 subscribersChannel
    Recommended with reservationsReviewed in English
    Recommended for
    Horror fans who can accept a stealth-focused game and a muddled story, and who don't mind the weak Silent Hill connection.
    With these reservations
    The story is confusing and contradictory, the stalker sections are unfair, the interiors and nightmare zones are repetitive, and it has little replay value.

    Combat

    • PraiseThe stealth system is engaging, though fairly generic.at 51:47
    • CriticismMelee is weak, grabs can't be blocked or escaped easily, and enemies can attack during stuns.at 51:35

    Story

    • PraiseThe backstory, told through notes and documents, is compelling and well built.at 17:39
    • CriticismThe main story is messy and contradictory, and the characters' current arcs are hard to follow.at 29:27

    Difficulty

    • CriticismThe stalker sections in darkness are frustrating on nightmare, with enemies hard to avoid.at 52:01

    Performance

    • CriticismOn PC, the outdoor zones have distracting stuttering.at 44:45
    Open the original review
  11. Albert Gil

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.54,200 subscribersChannel
    RecommendedReviewed in Spanish
    Recommended for
    Quien disfrute del sigilo con tensión, los puzles densos, la ambientación inmersiva y una historia clara con temas maduros.
    With these reservations
    Combate pobre, poca variedad de enemigos, ritmo lento en las fases de sigilo, enemigo Weight frustrante, puzles finales muy duros y rendimiento irregular al inicio en PC.

    Combat

    • CriticismEl combate cuerpo a cuerpo es muy básico: solo golpear y bloquear, sin parry ni esquiva.at 10:38

    Story

    • PraiseLa historia se sigue bien y trata temas sociales y adultos que la saga no había abordado antes.at 19:06
    • CriticismQuien busque una trama más críptica puede encontrarla algo corta.at 20:08

    Difficulty

    • PraiseLos puzles son densos, exigen leer, examinar y deducir, y están a la altura de las mejores entregas.at 14:48
    • CriticismAlgunos puzles finales pueden resultar desesperantes.at 23:16
    • CriticismEl perseguidor Weight es frustrante, porque no se puede eliminar y basta con que te vea para morir.at 13:45

    Performance

    • CriticismEn la versión 1.0 de PC hay tirones mientras se compilan los sombreadores, y el rendimiento podría ser mejor.at 6:42
    Open the original review
  12. Shredded Otaku

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.35,700 subscribersChannel
    Recommended with reservationsReviewed in English
    With these reservations
    Repeated backtracking through enemy-filled areas feels tedious, and the stealth mechanics are imperfect.

    Combat

    • PraiseStealth-focused, avoidance-based encounters work well despite feeling unlike classic Silent Hill.at 0:19
    • CriticismBacktracking forces repeated enemy avoidance, which becomes tedious.at 0:31
    • CriticismThe stealth mechanics are described as less than perfect.at 1:02

    Story

    • PraiseThe reviewer finds the narrative and setting unsettling and gripping.at 0:46
    • PraiseMystery and atmosphere keep the reviewer pushing forward despite flaws.at 1:03
    Open the original review
  13. Hikikomori Media

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.26,800 subscribersChannel
    Recommended with reservationsTheir own score: 6 / 10Reviewed in English
    Recommended for
    Players not expecting a typical Silent Hill experience; the reviewer says an audience exists without naming it.
    With these reservations
    Not fun, repetitive puzzles, frustrating stealth and performance issues, and it doesn't feel like Silent Hill.

    Combat

    • PraiseRichard's shotgun segments are the reviewer's favorite because they don't depend on stealth.at 22:50
    • CriticismThe pocket CRT tracks only one enemy at a time, and distance is hard to judge in first person.at 11:55
    • CriticismEnemies absorb many hits, even on normal difficulty.at 12:07
    • CriticismThe revolver needs a full clip per enemy and alerts others, and the flare gun's shots are erratic.at 12:27
    • CriticismThe gameplay is slow and generic, and not fun.at 39:26

    Story

    • PraiseThe story is decent once it picks up, though it takes a long, slow stretch to get there.at 39:26
    • CriticismSimon feels like a stranger with little personality.at 15:54
    • CriticismThe setting feels like an ordinary town, without the curse or spiritual mystery expected from Silent Hill.at 25:45
    • CriticismSimon's punishment in the purgatory loop doesn't make narrative sense, since he had little agency.at 36:22

    Difficulty

    • PraiseZoe's puzzle is elaborate and stayed challenging even after patches.at 22:08
    • CriticismThe Wait is nearly unbeatable and can still kill after knockout, even after the rebalance.at 14:55
    • CriticismMost puzzles are repetitive combination locks and drawer searches.at 30:10
    • CriticismA patch simplified the hardest puzzles, including the final one, which removed much of the challenge.at 33:14

    Performance

    • CriticismThrowing an item made the frame rate drop to about 10 fps.at 15:13
    Open the original review
  14. Molotov Game

    We could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.3,620 subscribersChannel
    No Verdict declaredReviewed in Russian

    Story

    • PraiseАвтор считает финал со справедливостью самым логичным из возможных и лучше всего завершающим историю.at 31:50
    • PraiseГород показан не просто декорацией, а полноценным участником событий, который рассказывает свою историю.at 1:21
    • PraiseСмысл противников раскрывается постепенно, после знакомства с историей, и это ценный приём игры.at 24:54
    • PraiseФинальный босс построен как образ трёх слоёв вины героя, и это выглядит продуманно.at 29:38
    Open the original review

Are you the creator of one of these reviews? Ask us to remove it.

Full description and technical details

Silent Hill: Townfall is a full-length, self-contained psychological horror set against the cold, isolated backdrop of Scotland, 1996. Players can explore St. Amelia, where fog-soaked streets, abandoned communities, and forgotten corners tell their story through atmosphere and history. Reality and delusion subtly intertwine to lure players into the depths of St. Amelia's grounded, tangible world.

  • Release date:2026-09-24
  • Studio:Screen Burn
  • Genres:Puzzle, Adventure
  • Platforms:PC (Microsoft Windows), PlayStation 5