What the sources said
What the sources say
What they praise most
- StoryСюжет цепляет и запутывает, персонажи запоминаются.StopGameat 24:47
- CombatСтелс удобен: есть укрытия, обходные пути и возможность выглядывать из-за углов.StopGameat 20:18
- DifficultyPuzzles are creative, make you think, and some are among the most memorable in the series.MoistCr1TiKaL Gamingat 6:04
What they criticise
- StoryFound the lore a bit confusing, though the game still held together.Dawkoat 1:50:02
- CombatУдары палкой ощущаются без веса, а враги атакуют резко и без паузы.StopGameat 20:33
- DifficultyНеубиваемый преследователь почти неубиваем, а на сложной сложности врагов становится больше и урон выше.StopGameat 23:25
Where the sources agree, and where they don't
They agree on
- LengthAll 4 sources criticise it
They disagree on
- CombatStopGame praises it and criticises it · Dawko criticises it · GENuINE993 criticises it · MoistCr1TiKaL Gaming praises it and criticises it · GmanLives criticises it · Cohh praises it and criticises it · XGTV UA praises it and criticises it · BaityPlays criticises it · Under The Mayo praises it and criticises it · Albert Gil criticises it · Shredded Otaku praises it and criticises it · Hikikomori Media praises it and criticises it
- StoryStopGame praises it · Dawko criticises it · GENuINE993 praises it and criticises it · MoistCr1TiKaL Gaming praises it and criticises it · PSI Gaming praises it and criticises it · XGTV UA praises it and criticises it · Under The Mayo praises it and criticises it · Albert Gil praises it and criticises it · Shredded Otaku praises it · Hikikomori Media praises it and criticises it · Molotov Game praises it
- DifficultyStopGame criticises it · Dawko criticises it · GENuINE993 criticises it · MoistCr1TiKaL Gaming praises it · GmanLives criticises it · XGTV UA praises it and criticises it · BaityPlays praises it and criticises it · Under The Mayo criticises it · Albert Gil praises it and criticises it · Hikikomori Media praises it and criticises it
- PerformanceStopGame praises it and criticises it · Dawko criticises it · GENuINE993 criticises it · XGTV UA praises it and criticises it · Under The Mayo criticises it · Albert Gil criticises it · Hikikomori Media criticises it
- PriceGmanLives praises it · XGTV UA criticises it
Only the sources we have a review from are listed. A source missing here is one we have no review from for this game — not proof that it said nothing about it, and not a verdict against it.
Combat
Dawko
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismFelt the final boss fight was underwhelming.at 1:50:04
GENuINE993
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismLas armas cuerpo a cuerpo se gastan enseguida y el combate se vuelve complicado.at 2:59:18
MoistCr1TiKaL Gaming
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismStealth is the main weakness: enemies are passed by waiting for them to look away, with few tools and little depth.at 1:08
- CriticismMelee combat with improvised weapons feels clunky and unsatisfying.at 1:48
- CriticismThe reviewer finds the forced waiting around enemies tedious and says it drags down the pace of exploration.at 2:10
- PraiseThe villain section offers a more action-focused change of pace that suits the character.at 9:06
BaityPlays
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismEl combate le parece flojo.at 37:19
- CriticismEl enemigo de sigilo es impredecible y eso le quita gracia.at 4:13:31
Under The Mayo
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.Albert Gil
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismEl combate cuerpo a cuerpo es muy básico: solo golpear y bloquear, sin parry ni esquiva.at 10:38
Shredded Otaku
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.Hikikomori Media
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismThe pocket CRT tracks only one enemy at a time, and distance is hard to judge in first person.at 11:55
- CriticismEnemies absorb many hits, even on normal difficulty.at 12:07
- CriticismThe revolver needs a full clip per enemy and alerts others, and the flare gun's shots are erratic.at 12:27
- PraiseRichard's shotgun segments are the reviewer's favorite because they don't depend on stealth.at 22:50
- CriticismThe gameplay is slow and generic, and not fun.at 39:26
Story
Dawko
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismFound the lore a bit confusing, though the game still held together.at 1:50:02
GENuINE993
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- PraiseAl principio la trama le parece prometedora.at 36:48
- CriticismAdmite no entender varios puntos de la trama al final.at 9:20:28
MoistCr1TiKaL Gaming
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.PSI Gaming
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.Under The Mayo
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.Albert Gil
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.Shredded Otaku
PraiseChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.Hikikomori Media
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismSimon feels like a stranger with little personality.at 15:54
- CriticismThe setting feels like an ordinary town, without the curse or spiritual mystery expected from Silent Hill.at 25:45
- PraiseThe story is decent once it picks up, though it takes a long, slow stretch to get there.at 39:26
- CriticismSimon's punishment in the purgatory loop doesn't make narrative sense, since he had little agency.at 36:22
Molotov Game
PraiseChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- PraiseАвтор считает финал со справедливостью самым логичным из возможных и лучше всего завершающим историю.at 31:50
- PraiseГород показан не просто декорацией, а полноценным участником событий, который рассказывает свою историю.at 1:21
- PraiseСмысл противников раскрывается постепенно, после знакомства с историей, и это ценный приём игры.at 24:54
- PraiseФинальный босс построен как образ трёх слоёв вины героя, и это выглядит продуманно.at 29:38
Difficulty
Dawko
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismFound the puzzles and back-and-forth progression complicated.at 1:50:30
GENuINE993
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismConsidera los puzles pesados, de lo peor del juego.at 9:18:47
MoistCr1TiKaL Gaming
PraiseChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- PraisePuzzles are creative, make you think, and some are among the most memorable in the series.at 6:04
XGTV UA
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismНевразливий монстр і довга анімація смерті роблять стелс душним.at 7:57
- CriticismРесурсів мало, особливо на середній складності.at 12:38
- PraiseГоловоломки потребують логіки й уваги, і вони приємно здивували.at 14:05
- CriticismТекст підказки для головоломок не змінюється залежно від складності.at 13:17
BaityPlays
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismLos puzzles finales son duros, y entender qué piden cuesta más que resolverlos.at 4:13:33
- PraiseHasta cierto punto, los puzzles no le parecen excesivamente obtusos.at 2:04:26
Under The Mayo
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismThe stalker sections in darkness are frustrating on nightmare, with enemies hard to avoid.at 52:01
Albert Gil
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- PraiseLos puzles son densos, exigen leer, examinar y deducir, y están a la altura de las mejores entregas.at 14:48
- CriticismAlgunos puzles finales pueden resultar desesperantes.at 23:16
- CriticismEl perseguidor Weight es frustrante, porque no se puede eliminar y basta con que te vea para morir.at 13:45
Hikikomori Media
MixedChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismThe Wait is nearly unbeatable and can still kill after knockout, even after the rebalance.at 14:55
- PraiseZoe's puzzle is elaborate and stayed challenging even after patches.at 22:08
- CriticismMost puzzles are repetitive combination locks and drawer searches.at 30:10
- CriticismA patch simplified the hardest puzzles, including the final one, which removed much of the challenge.at 33:14
Performance
Dawko
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismSaid the optimization is poor, with lag and a camera that froze during play.at 1:13:24
GENuINE993
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismSufrió bloqueos y bugs durante la partida.at 8:22:23
Under The Mayo
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismOn PC, the outdoor zones have distracting stuttering.at 44:45
Albert Gil
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismEn la versión 1.0 de PC hay tirones mientras se compilan los sombreadores, y el rendimiento podría ser mejor.at 6:42
Hikikomori Media
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismThrowing an item made the frame rate drop to about 10 fps.at 15:13
Length
GENuINE993
CriticismChannelWe could not check this video for community-marked advertising segments.- CriticismLo ve excesivamente largo y poco rejugable.at 9:18:17
Monetisation
We have no claim about this aspect in the reviews shown here. It may well have been covered and we simply have not captured it, so this is not a sign that nobody said anything about it.
Co-op
We have no claim about this aspect in the reviews shown here. It may well have been covered and we simply have not captured it, so this is not a sign that nobody said anything about it.
Price
Are you the creator of one of these reviews? Ask us to remove it.
Full description and technical details
Silent Hill: Townfall is a full-length, self-contained psychological horror set against the cold, isolated backdrop of Scotland, 1996. Players can explore St. Amelia, where fog-soaked streets, abandoned communities, and forgotten corners tell their story through atmosphere and history. Reality and delusion subtly intertwine to lure players into the depths of St. Amelia's grounded, tangible world.
- Release date:2026-09-24
- Studio:Screen Burn
- Genres:Puzzle, Adventure
- Platforms:PC (Microsoft Windows), PlayStation 5